While the military emphasizes the importance of the chain of command and obedience to orders, history reveals numerous instances of individuals defying directives. Motivations for disobedience vary, ranging from moral objections, as seen in Colonel Raoul Berube’s refusal to fire on his troops during WWI, to personal ambitions, exemplified by Union General Daniel Sickles in the Civil War.
Stanislav Petrov Disregarded A Missile Warning, Averting WWIII


More than 20 years after Vasili Arkhipov prevented nuclear war during the Cuban Missile Crisis, Lt. Colonel Stanislav Petrov faced a similar critical decision. On September 26, 1983, stationed at the Serpukhov-15 bunker near Moscow, Petrov’s early warning system detected a potential American ICBM.
Despite the pressure, Petrov correctly identified it as a false alarm caused by sunlight reflecting off clouds, preventing a catastrophic nuclear exchange. Recognized for his crucial decision, Petrov received the World Citizen Award in 2004 and the Dresden Peace Prize in 2013 for being “The Man Who Saved The World.”
Soviet Sub Officer Vasili Arkhipov Kept The Cuban Missile Crisis From Escalating
The B-59 submarine, armed with a powerful nuclear missile, was ordered to attack American forces if provoked. When the U.S. navy dropped depth charges near the submarine, Captain Valentin Savitski, believing war had started, ordered the missile launch. However, fleet commander Vasili Alexandrovich Arkhipov, recognizing the situation differently, successfully persuaded Savitski to stand down, preventing a catastrophic nuclear confrontation.


Lt. David Teich Sent Four Tanks To Help Another Unit, Defying Orders To Withdraw
On April 22, 1951, during the Korean War, the Chinese Army launched the Spring Offensive, deploying 300,000 troops against American forces. Two days into the offensive, as American forces faced overwhelming attacks, a unit from the 8th Ranger Company, led by Commander E.C. Rivera, found itself isolated. Rivera called for help, but the remaining American forces opted to retreat.
In a decisive act of disobedience, Lieutenant Dave Teich defied his captain’s orders and dispatched four tanks to Hill 628, rescuing Rivera and his 65 stranded men from imminent danger.


Cpl. Desmond Doss Refused A Weapon But Became A Hero
As a combat medic for the 77th Infantry, he refused to carry a weapon and faced criticism from fellow soldiers. However, Doss earned the respect of his squadmates in combat, receiving a Bronze Star for heroism on Leyte and becoming renowned for saving approximately 75 wounded soldiers under heavy gunfire during the Battle of Okinawa. His actions led to him being awarded the Medal of Honor, making him the sole conscientious objector in WWII to receive this honor.


Aussie Lt. ‘Diver’ Derrick Said ‘Bugger The CO’ And Captured A Japanese Position
During WWII, the 2/48th Battalion of the Australian 9th Infantry Division emerged as Australia’s most decorated unit, with Lt. Thomas “Diver” Derrick standing out as one of its highly decorated and revered soldiers. His notable feat occurred during the Battle of Sattelberg in New Guinea in November 1943. Facing a stalled advance and a commanding officer ordering a retreat, Derrick boldly declared, “Bugger the CO, just give me 20 minutes and we’ll have this place.”
Undeterred, Derrick single-handedly advanced uphill through the jungle, clearing out 10 Japanese machine gun positions with covering fire from his squadmates. His fearless actions not only secured the unit’s objective but also earned him the Victoria Cross, the highest military decoration. Tragically, Derrick sustained severe injuries during the Battle of Tarakan in May 1945, ultimately succumbing the following day.


General Dietrich Von Choltitz Declined To Burn Paris As His Troops Evacuated The City
During the Allied invasion of northern France on D-Day in June 1944, followed by the capture of Paris in August, Adolf Hitler ordered local forces to burn down the city to prevent it from falling into enemy hands. This directive included destroying vital infrastructure, war-related facilities, and iconic landmarks like Notre Dame Cathedral and the Arc de Triomphe.
The commander of the First German Army, General Dietrich von Choltitz, refused to carry out these destructive orders. In his 1951 memoirs, von Choltitz claimed the orders lacked military value and criticized Hitler’s mental state. However, some French observers contend that Choltitz may have lacked the necessary troops to execute the orders and suggest that he later sought to reshape the narrative to protect his reputation.


As WWII Ended, Albert Speer Refused To Destroy Germany’s Civilian Infrastructure


WWI Artillery Commander Raoul Berube Refused A General’s Order To Fire On His Men
When the divisional commander, General Geraud Reveilhac, ordered another charge, the 21st company refused, and subsequent orders to fire on his own troops were refused by artillery commander Colonel Berube. Despite this, Reveilhac retained command until February 1916, received honors after the war, and retired. The incident was later depicted in the film “Paths of Glory.”


When Augustus Died, Roman Soldiers On The Rhine Mutinied, Causing An Imperial Crisis
However, a Senate delegation’s investigation reignited the mutiny. Threatened with harm to his family, Germanicus reproached the soldiers for endangering Augustus’s descendants, leading to the execution of ringleaders. Germanicus then successfully led the formerly rebellious soldiers on a Rhine expedition, confirming their loyalty.


Indian Soldiers Refused Cartridges Greased With Pork And Beef Fat, Triggering The 1857 Rebellion


Union General Dan Sickles Moved 10,000 Men Out Of Position
In the Battle of Gettysburg, General Daniel Sickles’ disobedience of orders is a subject of debate. As a Tammany Hall politician with presidential ambitions, Sickles sought to improve his reputation by raising a brigade at the outbreak of the Civil War. On July 2, 1863, despite Major General George S. Meade’s refusal, Sickles advanced his III Corps to a forward position, leaving Little Round Top undefended.
The subsequent Confederate attack forced Sickles to retreat, resulting in significant casualties. The defense of Little Round Top fell to other units, notably the 20th Maine under Colonel Joshua Chamberlain. Sickles argued that his insubordination helped the Army of the Potomac survive, a claim contested by many historians. Despite differing opinions, some still consider Sickles may have had a point.


Nelson Mandela Spent Time In Prison For Activism


Wangari Maathai, A Kenyan environmentalist and political activist


Liu Xiaobo, A Chinese intellectual and human rights activist


Mohandas Gandhi, leader of the Indian independence movement against British rule


Galileo Galilei and Heliocentrism


Julius Caesar, Roman general and statesman


Rosa Parks, African American civil rights activist


Martin Luther, German monk and theologian


Dakota Meyer, United States Marine Corps veteran


Daniel Hellings Saved His Fellow Soldier


Benaya Rein Protected His Unit Against Orders


Sophocles’s Antigone


Henry David Thoreau, American philosopher and author


Alvin York, Conscientious Objector


Mahatma Gandhi’s Salt March


Harriet Tubman, American abolitionist and political activist


Emmeline Pankhurst, British political activist and leader of the British suffragette movement


Martin Luther King Jr., American Baptist minister and activist


Susan B. Anthony, key figure in the women’s suffrage movement in the United States


Lech Wałęsa, Polish labor leader and human rights activist


Please SHARE this with your friends and family.