30+ Unexpected Costco Items That Have Become Cult Favorites Since People Can’t Stop Buying Them

Oh, Costco, keepers of bulk items that we can’t help but make room for in our pantries and refrigerators. From giant vats of olive oil to a neighborhood’s worth of nuts, it’s clear the Costco holds a special place in the hearts of Americans who love to stock up and save a few bucks.

And there are some cult items we wish we had never discovered. Remember when those chocolate-covered potato chips sounded kind of gross, but you agreed to try them anyway and now you can’t stop yourself from grabbing another container every week? Ah, the memories.

Here are 35 of the most popular items people can’t resist picking up from their local Costco. How many have you snagged during your weekly grocery shopping or a pre-party food run?